Urban Legend

Alicia Witt

Natalie Simon

Jared Leto

Paul Gardener

Rebecca Gayheart

Brenda Bates

Michael Rosenbaum

Parker Riley

Loretta Devine

Reese Wilson

Tara Reid

Sasha Thomas

John Neville

Dean Adams

Joshua Jackson

Damon Brooks

Julian Richings

Weird Janitor

Robert Englund

Professor William Wexler

Danielle Harris

Tosh Guaneri

Natasha Gregson Wagner

Michelle Mancini

Gord Martineau

David McAree

Vince Corazza

David Evans

Stephanie Mills

Felicia

Danny Comden

Blake

Nancy McAlear

Jenny

Kay Hawtrey

Library Attendant

Angela Vint

Bitchy Girl

J.C. Kenny

Weather Lady

Balázs Koós

Nerdy Guy

Shawn Mathieson

Hippie Guy

Clé Bennett

Dorky Guy

Danielle Brett

Trendy Girl

Roberta Angelica

Swimming Woman

Matt Birman

Killer

Brad Dourif

Michael McDonnell, Gas Station Attendant (non-crédité)